Military historian praises 'realistic' movies 'better than Saving Private Ryan'

When it comes to war films, Saving Private Ryan, which some film fans claim has been dethroned by a newly released Netflix hit as the "greatest" war movie , is often regarded as one of the most intense, especially for its depiction of the D-Day landings. The movie's most iconic scene was famously improvised, but many movie fans found this 'distasteful.' However, according to a seasoned Army historian, it falls short in terms of accuracy, failing to make his top-five list.

Dave Hogan, who recently retired after a 37-year tenure at the US Army Centre for Military History, has compiled a list of the top five films that "accurately portray U.S. soldiers and combat operations.



" Although the Omaha Beach scene in Saving Private Ryan is frequently lauded for its authenticity, Hogan asserts that The Thin Red Line is the film that truly captures the experience of US soldiers in combat. Josh Duhammel's wife didn't know her scene in Netflix's Ransom Canyon was 'cut' Jennifer Aniston's 'perfect' Netflix movie that has fans canceling their plans to watch Based on James Jones's novel, The Thin Red Line is a war film that tells the story of the 1943 Battle for Guadalcanal's Mount Austen in the Solomon Islands. It follows members of the 25th Infantry Division who went missing and attempted to live among the native Melanesians.

Hogan argued that this film was more convincing than Saving Private Ryan, which, in his opinion, felt like a "typical World War II movie" beyond the opening Omaha Beach scenes, which he commended. In an army news release, Hogan explained: "I just felt that the whole premise, sending a unit deep behind enemy lines, through disputed territory to try to just notify this guy that he no longer had to serve, was just far-fetched." "There was something about that movie, that I just found more convincing than [the 1998 World War II film] Saving Private Ryan in terms of how it portrayed the way Nick Nolte plays the officer and trying to make this advance against an unseen enemy.

" The other films on his list were: Fury; From Here to Eternity; Cold Mountain; and Black Hawk Down. That said, military news outlet Task and Purpose held a differing opinion, contending that the harrowing first scenes of Saving Private Ryan, capturing the horror of German machine guns, displayed a realism previously unseen on film. While conceding that there is room for improvement in certain areas of Saving Private Ryan, Task and Purpose maintained that its depiction of battle established a new standard for realism.

.